didericis
e47f89918a
User correctly pointed out:
(1) The Figure 4 partial-tire-dual interior structure is not a "theta
graph" in the K_{2,3} sense (which requires all three paths of
length ≥ 2). It is θ(1, 6, 6): a 12-cycle with one chord.
(2) θ(1, p, q) IS outerplanar (just a polygon with one chord), so it
belongs IN the menagerie, not outside it.
Revisions:
- Section 6 ("2-connected outerplanar with Δ ≤ 3"): previously claimed
the class is just cycles; corrected to "cycle, possibly with a
matching of chords." Added explicit description of θ(1, p, q) and
a closed-form for its proper 3-edge-coloring count:
P_e(θ(1,p,q), 3) = (2^{p+q} - 2^p (-1)^q - 2^q (-1)^p + 10 (-1)^{p+q}) / 3.
Verified against Sage's chromatic polynomial for all p, q ∈ {2..6}.
- "Outside the menagerie" section: previously said "theta graphs (all
flavours) are not outerplanar." Corrected to clarify that only
θ(p, q, r) with all three paths of length ≥ 2 (= K_{2,3} subdivisions)
is not outerplanar. Explicitly noted that the bridge-case partial
tire dual gives θ(1, p, q) which IS in the menagerie, with edge-3-
coloring count given by the closed form.
The Figure 4 partial-tire-dual (m=4 outer cycle + barbell O with
bridge) has θ(1, 6, 6) as its interior dual subgraph and so admits
exactly 1326 proper 3-edge-colorings on the interior cycle-with-
chord; leaves contribute their forced colors as in the spoke-only
case.
Paper unchanged. This is a correction within the notes/ subdir only.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com>