Captures the rationale for placing the MCP server outside the agent
container. The bottle wall doesn't strictly require it (the operator
TUI is the actual gate), but pattern consistency, audit metadata
trust, connection lifecycle, future enforcement headroom, and
pipelock cleanliness all argue for sidecar placement.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Replaces the text-only /supervise/notify protocol with three MCP tools
the agent calls directly: cred-proxy-block, pipelock-block, and
capability-block. Each tool carries the agent's proposed config file
(routes.json, pipelock allowlist, or Dockerfile) plus a justification.
Adds a new MCP sidecar, a read-only current-config mount in the agent
container, and renames "capability gap" to "capability block" to match
the tool name. The text-only-vs-structured tradeoff is captured as an
Open question with pros/cons on both sides.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Introduces cred-proxy block, pipelock block, and capability gap as the
three named categories of stuck. Adds pipelock-edit support (restart-
based for v1) parallel to the existing cred-proxy routes-edit path,
plus a pipelock audit log. Broadens Goals to cover all three paths.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Rewrites Scope, Proposed Design, Data model, and Open questions to
match the model where /supervise/notify is text-in/text-out, routes
edits + SIGHUP reload are supervisor-side tooling, and manifest
rebuilds are the heavy path. Adds the per-bottle routes-edit audit log.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com>
The autonomous "review comment → respawn bottle with comment as
next prompt" loop is the one feature that opens a prompt-injection
vector the bottle wall can't close (a public commenter would get
to issue instructions inside the agent's perimeter on every
launch). The available mitigations — commenter allowlists,
prompt-injection regex screens, private-repo defaults — are all
soft. The durable defense is to keep the human between the
review comment and any next agent prompt.
So `supervise` is now strictly notify-only. The `auto_respawn`
manifest field, the "with auto_respawn: true" behavior paragraph,
and the matching trust-model edge case all go. The reasoning
stays in the "Where to be conservative" bullet so the decision
isn't re-litigated later.
Brings the built-in supervisor research note (TUI + PR feedback design)
onto the agent-unstuck branch alongside the existing PRD 0012 +
companion research stack.
didericis