Resolve n=21 boundary: all four open Holton-McKay duals are bridge-derived

Backward bridge-switch search (sharded over valid parity partitions) found
an Even Level Graph witness for each of the four previously-open duals:
  dual 0: partition 12, witness orbit 9458
  dual 3: partition  9, witness orbit  388
  dual 4: partition 23, witness orbit 3842
  dual 5: partition 12, witness orbit 165668
So all four are bridge-derived level graphs, hence valid derived level
graphs. Combined with the two duals that are Even Level Graphs outright,
the disjunction is now confirmed for ALL SIX critical iso classes at n=21
-- the first nontrivial test of the conjecture passes.

Why it worked where exhaustion failed: a witness, when it exists, tends to
sit in a SMALL orbit (here a few hundred to ~1.7e5 states) reachable
quickly, while other parity partitions of the same triangulation have
orbits >1e6. We only need one good partition. The bridge restriction both
shrinks orbits ~100x and guarantees validity, so any ELG found in a
backward orbit is an immediate witness.

- Update paper n=21 subsection to report the resolution.
- Add shard_hunt.py (partition-sharded parallel witness hunt).

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
2026-05-22 10:50:13 -04:00
parent ad3f95fa39
commit 984655fd3d
5 changed files with 84 additions and 18 deletions
+19 -12
View File
@@ -365,19 +365,26 @@ source vertex), hence trivially valid derived level graphs. So the
disjunction holds for them through the derived-level-graph disjunct --
the first instances where that disjunct does work the intertwining-tree
disjunct cannot.
\item The remaining four are not Even Level Graphs for any source. A
bounded backward $E/O$-orbit search (tens of thousands of states, a
handful of source labellings) found no Even Level Graph in their
orbits, but this is far too shallow relative to the orbit size at
$n = 21$ to be conclusive; their status as derived level graphs is
open.
\item The remaining four are not Even Level Graphs for any source, and
their full $E/O$-orbits ($\sim\!10^8$ states per source labelling) are
far too large to exhaust. Restricting to \emph{bridge switches}
(Definition~\ref{def:bridge-switch}) shrinks the relevant orbits by
roughly two orders of magnitude and, crucially, keeps every reachable
triangulation valid. A backward bridge-switch search over the valid
parity partitions found an Even Level Graph witness for each of the
four, so all four are \emph{bridge-derived level graphs}
(Definition~\ref{def:bridge-derived-level-graph}) and hence valid
derived level graphs. The witnessing orbits are small -- between a few
hundred and $\sim\!1.7\times 10^5$ states -- even though other parity
partitions of the same triangulations have orbits exceeding $10^6$;
finding one good partition suffices.
\end{itemize}
Thus at $n = 21$ the disjunction is confirmed for two of the six
critical iso classes and undetermined for the other four. Settling
those four -- equivalently, deciding $E/O$-orbit reachability from an
Even Level Graph -- is the first genuinely open instance of the
conjecture, and calls for either a better reachability algorithm or a
structural invariant of $E/O$-orbits.
Thus at $n = 21$ the disjunction is confirmed for all six critical iso
classes: two are Even Level Graphs outright, and the other four are
bridge-derived level graphs. The bridge-switch restriction is what made
the search tractable -- it both shrinks the orbit and guarantees
validity, so any Even Level Graph located in a backward orbit is an
immediate witness.
\begin{thebibliography}{9}