even_level: add "Toward a characterization of bridge-derived graphs"
Record the partition sweep on the n=24 Fig 2.10 dual. New subsection + experiments/bridge_partition_sweep.py. Findings: - A bridge switch is a constrained diagonal flip; bridge-derived via L means lying in an Even-Level-Graph component of the restricted flip graph. So the question is which flip-components contain an ELG. - Identity: every 4-coloring of a triangulation has e_cross = 2n-4 (each face has one within-pair edge), so total parity-subgraph Betti = (c_A+c_B)-2; intertwining trees are the Betti-0 case. - Of T's 333 valid partitions, total Betti splits 288/42/3 over 1/2/3; min is 1 (T not intertwining). All 27 partitions found bridge-derived (depth 2-3) have the minimum Betti 1 -> necessary. - But not sufficient: only 27 of 288 Betti-1 partitions yield a witness; the rest have flip-orbits >1.5e5 with no ELG, and a 12x budget increase found none. The discriminator is flip-component structure (sharp orbit-size dichotomy), not a numerical invariant. Characterizing which Betti-minimal partitions sit in an ELG component is left open. Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
@@ -622,6 +622,58 @@ in particular no odd cycle, is created.}
|
||||
\label{fig:n24-dual}
|
||||
\end{figure}
|
||||
|
||||
\subsection*{Toward a characterization of bridge-derived graphs}
|
||||
|
||||
A bridge switch is a diagonal flip of the quadrilateral around a level
|
||||
edge, constrained so the flipped-in edge enters no parity subgraph as a
|
||||
cycle edge. Fixing a valid parity partition $L$, the bridge switches
|
||||
therefore act on the triangulations whose two $L$-parity subgraphs are
|
||||
both bipartite, and $G$ is a bridge-derived level graph via $L$ exactly
|
||||
when $G$ lies in the same connected component as an Even Level Graph in
|
||||
this restricted flip graph. So the question ``which triangulations are
|
||||
bridge-derived?'' is really ``which flip-components contain an Even Level
|
||||
Graph?'', quantified over $L$. We probed this on the $24$-vertex dual $T$
|
||||
of Figure~\ref{fig:n24-dual}, sweeping all of its valid parity partitions;
|
||||
the experiment is recorded in \texttt{experiments/bridge\_partition\_sweep.py}.
|
||||
|
||||
One coordinate organises the picture. For any proper $4$-coloring of a
|
||||
triangulation, group the colours as $\{1,2\}\mid\{3,4\}$; then each
|
||||
triangular face has exactly one within-pair edge, and since there are
|
||||
$2n-4$ faces and each edge lies on two of them, the parity subgraphs carry
|
||||
exactly $n-2$ edges between them. Hence $e_{\mathrm{cross}} = 2n-4$ for
|
||||
\emph{every} valid partition (confirmed across all partitions of $T$), and
|
||||
the total first Betti number of the two parity subgraphs equals
|
||||
$(c_A + c_B) - 2$, where $c_A, c_B$ count their connected components. The
|
||||
intertwining-tree case is precisely total Betti $0$ -- both parts trees,
|
||||
$c_A = c_B = 1$ -- so for a triangulation that is not an intertwining tree
|
||||
the total Betti is at least $1$.
|
||||
|
||||
The $333$ valid partitions of $T$ have total Betti $1$, $2$, $3$ for
|
||||
$288$, $42$, $3$ of them respectively; the minimum is $1$, consistent with
|
||||
$T$ not being an intertwining tree. A backward bridge-orbit search locates
|
||||
Even Level Graph witnesses (at depth $2$--$3$) for $27$ partitions, and
|
||||
\emph{every} one of them has the minimum total Betti $1$ -- one parity
|
||||
class a tree, the other a tree plus a single even cycle. Minimal total
|
||||
Betti is thus a necessary feature of the bridge-derived partitions we
|
||||
find.
|
||||
|
||||
It is not sufficient, and the way it fails is informative. Of the $288$
|
||||
Betti-$1$ partitions only those $27$ yield a witness; the rest exhibit
|
||||
bridge-orbits exceeding $1.5\times 10^5$ states with no Even Level Graph,
|
||||
and increasing the search budget twelvefold produced no further witnesses.
|
||||
The bridge-derivable partitions are separated from the others not by any
|
||||
of the simple invariants we measured -- total Betti, component counts,
|
||||
class sizes, or BFS-level realizability (uniformly false here) -- but by a
|
||||
sharp dichotomy in flip-orbit size: a tiny component containing an Even
|
||||
Level Graph versus a vast one that appears not to. (We cannot yet certify
|
||||
the latter, as no large orbit was exhausted; but a twelvefold budget
|
||||
increase yielding nothing makes mere depth an unlikely explanation.) The
|
||||
evidence therefore points away from a numerical characterization and
|
||||
toward the component structure of the restricted flip graph: minimal total
|
||||
Betti is a clean necessary condition, but characterizing \emph{which}
|
||||
Betti-minimal partitions lie in an Even-Level-Graph component remains open
|
||||
and is, on this evidence, the crux of deciding bridge-derivability.
|
||||
|
||||
\begin{thebibliography}{9}
|
||||
|
||||
\bibitem{holton-mckay}
|
||||
|
||||
Reference in New Issue
Block a user