even_level: extend to n=25 -- second internally-6-connected core, also bridge-derived

Enumerate non-Hamiltonian cyclically-5-connected cubic planar graphs by
running plantri -c5 -d for n in {23,25,26} (n=24 already in the previous
commit) and filtering for non-Hamiltonian dual:
  n=23  -> 0 of 1970   (recomputes Faulkner-Younger minimality)
  n=24  -> 1 of 6833   (the Tutte/Fig 2.10 graph)
  n=25  -> 1 of 23384  (new; unique 46-vertex one)
  n=26  -> 0 of 82625

Both T (n=24) and T_25 (n=25) verified internally 6-connected by exhaustive
5-cut scan: every 5-cut is the neighborhood of a degree-5 vertex. This is
the strongest connectivity a planar triangulation can have and the level
at which Birkhoff-style reductions terminate, so both are genuinely
irreducible bases of any decomposition argument.

T_25 is also bridge-derived: witness Even Level Graph from source 24
(max level 4) at depth 2, orbit only 3114 states. Forward switches:
remove {21,23} add {22,24}; remove {3,5} add {1,6}. Both adds are bridges
of the even parity subgraph. Same witness signature as T (minimum total
Betti, tiny orbit, depth 2).

New subsection "Beyond n=24: enumeration and the next 5-connected core",
abstract extended, new Figure 7 (core_n25_dual.png). Reproducibility
scripts: draw_core_witness.py and verify_core_witness.py (both
parametrized so they work on any 5-conn non-Ham-dual core's g6).

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.7 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
This commit is contained in:
2026-05-22 20:13:24 -04:00
parent 1791b68f4a
commit 20f19f0869
9 changed files with 457 additions and 58 deletions
+85 -3
View File
@@ -112,7 +112,15 @@ the unique $44$-vertex non-Hamiltonian \emph{cyclically $5$-connected}
cubic planar graph -- settling a uniqueness question Holton--McKay left
open -- whose $24$-vertex $5$-connected dual is the first test of the
conjecture outside the $3$-cut family; it too is a bridge-derived level
graph, two bridge switches from an Even Level Graph.
graph, two bridge switches from an Even Level Graph. Iterating the same
generation procedure up to $n = 26$ produces, at $n = 25$, a second
non-Hamiltonian cyclically-$5$-connected cubic planar graph (likewise
unique at its size); its dual is verified \emph{internally
$6$-connected} -- the strongest connectivity possible for a planar
triangulation, and the level at which Birkhoff-style reductions
terminate -- and likewise bridge-derived, again at depth $2$. Both known
internally-$6$-connected non-Hamiltonian-dual cores thus satisfy the
conjecture, with identical witness signature.
\end{abstract}
\maketitle
@@ -586,8 +594,8 @@ non-Hamiltonian cyclically $5$-connected cubic planar graph on $44$
vertices.
Let $T$ be its dual: a $24$-vertex triangulation with vertex connectivity
$5$ and no separating triangle, and -- since its dual is non-Hamiltonian
-- not an intertwining tree. We find that $T$ is nonetheless a
$5$ (in fact internally $6$-connected, verified in the next subsection),
and -- since its dual is non-Hamiltonian -- not an intertwining tree. We find that $T$ is nonetheless a
bridge-derived level graph. Of its $333$ valid parity partitions most are
useless: their backward bridge-orbits exceed $8 \times 10^5$ states with
no Even Level Graph in sight. But one partition has a backward orbit of
@@ -622,6 +630,80 @@ in particular no odd cycle, is created.}
\label{fig:n24-dual}
\end{figure}
\subsection*{Beyond $n = 24$: enumeration and the next $5$-connected core}
The graph $T$ of the previous subsection is one core; iterating the same
generation procedure produces the rest. Below, the third column counts
$5$-connected triangulations on $n$ vertices (\texttt{plantri -c5} $n$),
and the fourth filters them by Hamiltonicity of the cubic dual:
\begin{center}
\begin{tabular}{cccc}
$n$ & dual $|V|$ & $5$-connected triangulations & non-Hamiltonian dual \\\hline
$23$ & $42$ & $1{,}970$ & $0$ \\
$24$ & $44$ & $6{,}833$ & $1$ \quad (Holton--McKay Fig.~2.10) \\
$25$ & $46$ & $23{,}384$ & $1$ \\
$26$ & $48$ & $82{,}625$ & $0$ \\
\end{tabular}
\end{center}
The $n = 23$ row recomputes Faulkner--Younger's minimality (no cyclically
$5$-connected non-Hamiltonian cubic planar graph below $44$ vertices). At
$n = 25$ we find a single new cyclically $5$-connected non-Hamiltonian
cubic planar graph on $46$ vertices; its dual we call $T_{25}$, a
$25$-vertex $5$-connected triangulation with degree sequence
$5^{21}\,8^{3}\,9^{1}$. At $n = 26$ there are again none. (All counts
depend on the correctness of \texttt{plantri} and of the Hamiltonicity
test.)
An exhaustive scan of all $\binom{n}{5}$ candidate $5$-cuts confirms that
both $T$ and $T_{25}$ are \emph{internally $6$-connected}: every
$5$-element vertex cut is the neighbourhood of a single degree-$5$
vertex, so neither admits a nontrivial separation of size $\le 5$. This
is the strongest connectivity a planar triangulation can have -- planar
graphs are never $6$-connected, because every planar graph has a vertex
of degree $\le 5$ -- and it is the level at which Birkhoff-style
reductions terminate (a minimal counterexample to the four colour theorem
can be assumed internally $6$-connected). Both cores are therefore
genuinely irreducible bases of any decomposition-based argument: nothing
in the cut-decomposition can simplify them further.
The bridge-derivability test on $T_{25}$ follows the same recipe and
yields the same conclusion. Enumerating valid parity partitions and
ordering by total Betti, the minimum total Betti is $1$, and the very
first Betti-$1$ partition encountered with a small backward bridge-orbit
contains an Even Level Graph (source $s = 24$, maximum level $4$) at
depth $2$ in an orbit of $3{,}114$ states. The two bridge switches
carrying that Even Level Graph to $T_{25}$ are
\[
\text{remove } \{21,23\},\ \text{add } \{22,24\}
\quad\text{and}\quad
\text{remove } \{3,5\},\ \text{add } \{1,6\},
\]
each adding a same-parity edge that is a bridge of the even parity
subgraph; both steps are valid bridge switches
(Figure~\ref{fig:n25-dual}). The witness signature -- minimum total
Betti, a tiny bridge-orbit, a depth-$2$ Even Level Graph -- is the same
that worked on $T$, suggesting it is not an accident of the $n = 24$
example but the generic shape of bridge-derivability witnesses on
internally-$6$-connected non-Hamiltonian-dual cores. The conjecture thus
survives every irreducible small case the connectivity bound forces us
to face.
\begin{figure}[ht]
\centering
\includegraphics[width=0.7\textwidth]{figures/core_n25_dual.png}
\caption{The $25$-vertex dual $T_{25}$ of the unique $46$-vertex
non-Hamiltonian cyclically $5$-connected cubic planar graph -- the only
such cubic graph at $46$ vertices and the second internally
$6$-connected core known. Drawn crossing-free and coloured by parity
(blue even, orange odd) for its witness partition. $T_{25}$ is internally
$6$-connected and not an intertwining tree, yet is a bridge-derived level
graph: the two solid green edges $\{1,6\}$ and $\{22,24\}$ are the bridge
edges introduced by the two bridge switches carrying its witness Even
Level Graph (source $24$) to $T_{25}$. Each is a bridge of the even
parity subgraph.}
\label{fig:n25-dual}
\end{figure}
\subsection*{Toward a characterization of bridge-derived graphs}
A bridge switch is a diagonal flip of the quadrilateral around a level